Comments on: Holiday Mania Approaches: Take Control

By: Sharon Greenspan

Sharon Greenspan — Fri, 17 Oct 2008 13:38:58 +0000

Halloween. What are some good non-food items? I’m LMAO because I just heard a Trader Joe commercial which said that ‘packaged candy is so last year. What’s hot this year is soup broth. Yes, it comes in resealable containers. Kids love it as a base for soups. You’ll be the talk of the town.’ —yeah, talk of the town alright. Too funny! Or am I seriously out of touch?!?!

By: Holiday Hypermarket

Holiday Hypermarket — Wed, 15 Oct 2008 10:47:42 +0000

It seems to me that Christmas is getting promoted earlier and earlier every year. Yesterday I saw a christmas commercial – in October!

By: Lynn

Lynn — Sun, 12 Oct 2008 02:23:03 +0000

I actually talk in our book “Celebrate Green!” about how when I was a child, a piece of candy was a TREAT! I mean we never had access to candy unless it was at a birthday party or Halloween. There wasn’t candy in school (our grandson’s teacher gives it out for good behavior!) or at any friends’ homes. We weren’t inhaling high fructose corn syrup because most things were made from scratch (OK, I admit to being old, but we kept it this way with our kids too). So Halloween really was a treat for us. But today kids are exposed to so many sweets that Halloween ceases to be special. In our experience at giving out thousands of alternatives to conventional candy at last year’s Green Halloween events, we didn’t have a single child who complained. I’m convinced it’s because they don’t care nearly as much about getting candy as their parents do. You all are doing a great job for your kids and your communities.

By: Green Bean

Green Bean — Mon, 06 Oct 2008 04:10:46 +0000

So true! We haven’t changed that much in a generation and, when you read the kids books, they still celebrate the simple stuff like bobbing for apples.

Exactly! Kind of like “chestnuts roasting on an open fire,” eh…? — Lynn

By: Diane MacEachern

Diane MacEachern — Sun, 05 Oct 2008 14:00:44 +0000

One thing that helped me keep the holidays under control and more free of commercialism is not having the television on. We had one tv, and most of the time the kids were growing up it was in our bedroom. They were busy Saturday mornings and didn’t watch a lot of cartoons, so were thankfully spared from getting bombarded with messages about junk they should get during the holidays. I often ran into parents who were frantic about getting their hands on the latest tchochke, and I had no idea it was even on the market.

Yes, Diane, good point. We only allow PBS and videos/DVDs at our home on our one TV (soon to be made obsolete by the digital TV transition!) but my older boy still picks up on a lot of consumer messages from his friends and believe it or not, from the school. I knew I was in for it when at orientation night a teacher said they use this example to teach the first graders the difference between needs and wants: Do you want a video game or do you need a video game? Ai yi, yi…Lynn

By: Lisa

Lisa — Wed, 01 Oct 2008 14:47:31 +0000

I posted a blog about this. I don’t have kids which I think makes it all easier.

Hi Lisa, thanks for stopping by! Yes, I think it does make it easier! But still, you have to deal with other people’s kids….relatives, etc, right? I LOVE the name and art on your blog…so cute…Retro Housewife Goes Green! Check it out, folks! — Lynn

By: MamaBird/SurelyYouNest

MamaBird/SurelyYouNest — Wed, 01 Oct 2008 11:19:56 +0000

Maybe the market bottoming out will put a damper on new Cinderella’s-coach type displays. My grandparents developed their stewardship by growing up with nothing and then living through the Depression. Caring for your resources may be a natural byproduct of tough times….

Exactly, MamaBird! My father was born in 1916 (he had me very late in life!), so he was very much of that era. I grew up with aluminum foil being re-used constantly and things being repaired out in his workshop. Very often I think about how he would react to today’s throw-away society. But still, let’s hope things don’t get THAT bad. Actually, I’m doing so much work with eco-entrepreneurs that I’m really jazzed about the green collar jobs boom that’s heading our way. Thanks for your wonderful comments, as always, Jess! — Lynn

By: Jenn (The Green Parent)

Jenn (The Green Parent) — Wed, 01 Oct 2008 11:05:10 +0000

I couldn’t agree more Lynn (and Anna)! A lot of people think that if you’re trying to have a simpler, greener holiday than you are some kind of Scrooge that doesn’t want to have fun. But in reality, I ONLY want to have fun, and I don’t want it to get lost in piles of junky decorations, stressful holiday commitments, and unwanted holiday gifts.

Another spiritual sister….yes, Jenn, yes! It’s amazing how much energy it can take to convince people that you really are not into all that ….STUFF! Thanks for sharing, Jenn! — Lynn

By: Jennifer Taggart, TheSmartMama

Jennifer Taggart, TheSmartMama — Wed, 01 Oct 2008 03:24:55 +0000

I plan on sticking to some “old fashioned” Halloween activities. We’re making shrunken apples heads, just like I used to make with my mom. We’re making orange and black garland and spooky critter shapes out of construction paper. My kids have store bought costumes – I’m far from perfect – but we’re trying to make memories this Holiday season more than buy the “in” toy.

Sounds cool, Jennifer! I’d love to learn more about those shrunken apple heads – I’ve never heard of that! I would love to find a barn somewhere where we could go apple bobbing, just like I used to do. I described the apple bobbing tradition to Big Boy and he said it sounded “disgusting.” But I bet he would get over it! — Lynn

By: Anna (Green Talk)

Anna (Green Talk) — Wed, 01 Oct 2008 03:24:15 +0000

It is amazing how so much has changed since we were kids. Simple holidays have become cash register’s dreams, playing in your backyard has become scheduled play dates and activities, and a backyard pick up game has become a year long commitment for a particular sport.

Have we lost the art of having fun?

Amen, sister. You describe these changes so well, Anna. I think the kids are still having fun, but what we have lost is the ability to appreciate simplicity. Everything now is so materialistic – I still can’t get over the fact that kids expect presents (aka gift bags) for showing up at parties! And teachers and parenting experts report that children today are “less resilient” because they have no free time to figure out how to deal with problems on their own. There’s always a coach, teacher, parent, or babysitter hanging around….I’m lucky, I live in a pretty retro neighborhood where kids do still play in the backyard and have pick-up games of soccer at the bus stop…but it’s not like it was when I was growing up, that’s for sure. Thanks for your comment, Anna!